College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Viewpoint | Ultimate Frisbee -- ultimately not a real sport

By Mark Langer

Print this article

Published: Thursday, April 21, 2005

Updated: Sunday, August 17, 2008

It seems like every time I go out to enjoy some of Tufts' open green areas these days, I am confronted with the ultimate Frisbee team playing Frisbee. I make a point of saying that they are not playing ultimate, as they like to refer to it. Instead, they are simply playing Frisbee, just as hippies that play hackey sack are just playing hackey sack, not "Extreme Hackey Sack." And if anybody who plays hackey sack should try to tell you that hackey sack is their "sport," you would laugh at them. This should be our attitude toward ultimate Frisbee.

I do not want to stoop so low as to have to explain to you why ultimate Frisbee is not a real sport, and that even if it was, it would be a totally crappy sport. I try not to understand the rules. Let's just say that any "sport" where you stand in front of your opponent and say "One Mississippi, two Mississippi, three Mississippi ..." is far too close to calling out the time before you can blitz in touch football. Could you imagine the basketball team counting down the opponent's shot clock? Of course not, and that is because basketball is a real sport and ultimate Frisbee is not. There are a multitude of other reasons why Frisbee is not a sport, but I am sure you can figure them out on your own.

Frisbees, when used properly, can lead to quite a lot of fun. You can take them out to the green with your friends on a nice afternoon. You can take them to a party and play the old "I bet you I can fit five beers in this Frisbee" trick. You can take them to a Frisbee golf course and pretend you are playing Frisbee golf as opposed to just getting high in the woods. We can reap so much enjoyment from Frisbees, and yet there is this small enclave of ridiculous people who think that playing Frisbee should entail doing push-ups and running laps. They have a legitimate-looking website and bark at each other like football players while doing drills. They tell you about how hard their Frisbee workout was. A workout? To play Frisbee? Friends, let's leave playing Frisbee to the real experts: dirty hippies.

But let me come to some sort of legitimate point. I am tired of the Frisbee "team" always taking up Fletcher field, which, if reserved for anything, should naturally be reserved for a superior sport, such as softball or baseball. This position is strengthened by the fact that Fletcher Field is, in fact, a softball diamond. Do the football or hockey teams have territory battles over who gets to use the ice rink? Does the field hockey team fight for time on the basketball court? Certainly not. Each sport should stick to its field/arena/court. Unfortunately, Frisbee is not a real sport and therefore it has no field.

In fact, Fletcher should be reserved for nothing at all. It is the one Tufts athletic field that you do not have to be on a team to use. As my friends and I have been told several times while being kicked off the official baseball field by Officer Williams, "Go play on Fletcher. It is the only diamond that you don't have to be on an athletic team to use." Even though this means a downgrade from baseball to softball (although softball allows one to drink beer while playing, more evidence of its superiority over Frisbee), we obey like good Tufts students. And what happens when we get there? The Frisbee "team" is there taking up right and center field.

The most unbelievable thing is that the Frisbee people have convinced some administrators in the athletic department that it is a sport (I shudder at the thought that my tuition money might be used to pay for ultimate Frisbee jerseys or cones).

So when we logically tell the Frisbee people that we were using the field first, they take out their laminated paper saying that they have been given the right to the field. They act like WE, a legitimate intramural softball team, are intruding on THEIR field. On a softball field! I do not understand how they can set up their cones in the outfield and then get upset when they have to dodge fly balls. That is like going to sunbathe on the discus field during a track meet and then getting pissed because people keep throwing discuses at you. Can anyone really take seriously the idea that these Frisbee people are more entitled to the field than an IM softball team? Naturally, we try to be rude to them.

The funny thing is that the Frisbee people are the only ones that we have issues with. If two softball teams want to use the diamond, one waits its turn for the other to finish, or they play together in a spirit of camaraderie. Even though softball/baseball is clearly superior to all other sports played on Fletcher and even though Fletcher is unmistakably a softball field, we are still happy to share the field with the cricket players, soccer players, sun bathers, people walking dogs and the people playing Frisbee for fun. Everyone shares, compromises, and make room for one another. But the Frisbee "team?" Oh no. I admit that they try to be polite about it, but they set up their cones and courteously try to kick everyone off just the same.

Enough of this quasi-sport stuff. The athletic department needs to come to its senses and realize that playing Frisbee is not a real sport and stop giving the Frisbee people the right to use up Fletcher. Either that, or it needs to recognize ultimate Frisbee as a sport (I know it is ridiculous, but bear with me) and give them a field of their own. Fletcher should be a community field shared by everyone who wants to use it.

Mark Langer is a senior majoring in international letters and visual studies.

see the correction for this article here

Comments

15 comments
MrsT
Sun Sep 27 2009 16:30
Saying ultimate is not a sport is like saying soccer is not a sport. Ultimate is most similiar to soccer out of any sports, and the two main points of soccer are controlling the ball with your feet and the endurance aspect of running on a soccer field. Ultimate frisbees two main points are running, and controling the disc. Controlling the disc itself is very hard like controlling the soccer ball with your feet.
Logic
Mon Aug 31 2009 12:06
It says that this article was written in 2005, why is anyone commenting on it?
In any event... GO TUFTS-EPO
j.
Sun Aug 30 2009 10:47
You all sound ridiculous. Until this "sport" is a contact sport, televised, sponsored, "athletes" are paid or the Olympics Committee adopts it into the games...it will never be considered a sport. Regardless, those who play try to justify it as a sport, but they seem to be the only people who take it seriously. It's just a game.
Joey
Tue Jul 21 2009 10:54
its not a sport you losers its a past time for un athletic people
zack
Mon Jul 6 2009 19:30
dumb ass.. your an ignorant bastard
for real
Wed Jul 1 2009 23:25
your and idiot and im being nice!
KM.
Sat Jun 27 2009 01:08
Wow, softball . So tiring huh ? You know nothing about Ultimate , we bust our asses to work hard the whole time were in. To suceed you have to know all these throws, how to cut, how to catch, layout and such. You dare to say its not a sport ? try it , i bet you'd fail or you'll start to love it. your a little btch, ive been playing since middle school and ive played other sports softball and soccer and i LOVE Ultimate so much more. Its so much more tiring, but more skill is needed. plus its more exciting. So try it , i bet youll like it , and fail miserably.
k
Sat Jun 13 2009 00:08
This Author must be a complete idiot. if you even attempt to play ultimate as a sport i would gaurenteee (i know i cant spell) that you would not last 5 minutes playing at the normal speed of the game. it requires more fitness than soccer and alot more stamina than football or even baseball. i play 6 sports: rowing, baseball, soccer, football, ultimate, and volleyball and i have to say ultimate is one of the more tiring sports after rowing of course. but what you are saying is that an intramural team of softball (which if your a man than you should not even be playing softball) is not a legite sport either its a recreational thing. you swing a bat, run to a base and stop. or you sit in the field waiting for a ball to come your way. now i love baseball and i have been playing it ever since i was 4, but if you cant recognize ultimate as a sport then how can you recognize baseball? ultimate is alot more physically challenging. so try ultimate and see for yourself that you suck at it and cant last more than 5 minutes on the field playing at the normal play of the game. then after that try calling it not a sport. and when you argue about something not being a sport at least look it up and understand it first becuase you know nothing about the sport of ultimate
Fuzzy
Mon May 4 2009 08:57
There are probably some people out there who would shudder to think that their tuition money is supporting "Majors" like International Letters and Visual Studies when it could be used for something worthwhile... say, two-ply toilet paper? And it must upset them when they're looking for their Ed or Poly Sci class and the classrooms are all full of students staring at a PowerPoint of vowels with umlauts and accent marks over them.
Jeremy
Tue Apr 21 2009 16:24
I'm glad that you're hard earned tuition money is going towards your complete and utter lack of acceptance and diversity in this growing age. Before you write an essay on something you hate so much, get the terminology right. First of all, "Hackey Sack" is actually called footbag. "Ultimate Frisbee" is just ultimate. It's people like you that get in trouble because of their ignorant minds and mouths.
tim kates
Sun Dec 21 2008 10:58
Wow, interesting how you feel its necessary to degrade Ultimate as a sport. As someone else stated, you need to know enough about something to be able to tear it down, and you obviously don't know enough about Ultimate Frisbee to do so. There is a HUGE difference between recreational frisbee and ultimate. In ultimate, people bust there asses and tire out due to the fact that it is a real sport. When playing in a park with some friends, however, it is just a leisurely activities. I'm so sick of ignorant people with superiority complexes trying to degrade the validity of Ultimate as a sport. I played soccer for a long time and I can honestly say I get as much of a work out playing ultimate as i did soccer. Come to a tournament, watch and maybe learn, then I dare you to call it anything but a sport.
holla
Mon Dec 15 2008 22:01
agreed
Your name
Fri Nov 7 2008 04:34
so you feel you have the right to discredit frisbee as a sport, but you admit to knowing nothing about it? i shudder to think you're a senior and these are the persuasive skills you've learned.
juan valdez
Wed Nov 5 2008 21:47
do you realize that during that whole thing you contradicted youself?
Ultimate is a REAL sport it might not be as old as some but is a sport all the same.
there are world championships just like soccer and baseball and football and swimming and track and field.
so suck it up and do what you said SHARE
Dave Perry, Tufts '98 and member of Tufts Ultimate Team (Alum)
Sun Sep 14 2008 19:26
While this author does a great job of regurgitating tired and unoriginal stereotypes, it is obvious he is missing the entire point of the game. It's clear the sport of Ultimate and this author were not meant for each other.

The author does manage to muster one good point, "[Tufts] needs to recognize ultimate Frisbee as a sport... and give them a field of their own. Fletcher should be a community field shared by everyone who wants to use it."

What do you know.. an actual point that's worth reading!







log out