Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

A response to McCarthyite Zionism

Published: Monday, March 15, 2010

Updated: Monday, March 15, 2010 08:03

Response to McCarthyite Zionism

MCT

Der Judenstaat: It's German for "The State of the Jews." More than a century later, Theodor Herzl's vision of a democratic and Jewish homeland as described in his 1896 book "Der Judenstaat" has not only been fulfilled, but also exceeded the most optimistic of expectations. Despite being one of the world's smallest countries and having to constantly defend itself against existential military threats, Israel has truly thrived. Israel has managed in 60 years to have the highest per capita rate of university degrees and museums and the third−largest number of companies in the NASDAQ Stock Market, to develop the origins of the cell phone and maintain state−of−the−art desalination capabilities, among many other miraculous achievements. In recent years, Israel has been at the forefront of humanitarian missions around the world, with journalist Anderson Cooper of CNN recently praising the Israeli−run field hospital in earthquake−torn Haiti, which is estimated to have performed 140 life−saving operations in the matter of a week.

Though dissent may be stifled throughout the Arab world, Israel boasts one of the most transparent and multifaceted civil societies in the world. The State of Israel is highly ranked in civil liberties and was labeled as "Free" by the non−partisan organization Freedom House, a feat no other nation in the Middle East can boast. Domestic freedoms within Israel manifest themselves through exceptional women's and gay rights, freedom of the press and a vibrant political process. Israel is the only country in the Middle East to adopt gay rights legislation, such as recognizing foreign same−sex marriages and allowing gays to openly serve in the military. Furthermore, Tel Aviv is considered worldwide to be a hub for what the Israeli Ministry of Tourism calls "gay tourism," drawing in thousands of visitors yearly. With regard to women's rights, Israel was one of the first nations to have a female prime minister (the late Golda Meir), many female CEOs make up the ranks of Israel Fortune 500 companies and its first Olympic medal was awarded to female athlete Yael Arad in 1992 for judo. Within the political system, women have held critical leadership positions as speakers of Parliament, Supreme Court justices and prominent cabinet members. Freedom of the press is widely respected throughout Israel, with all newspapers privately owned and unrestrained in critiquing their own government.

Although Israel enjoys full diplomatic relations with only two members of the Arab League, Egypt and Jordan (20 out of 22 members refuse to recognize Israel's existence), it has attempted to make the most out of its relationships with its neighbors. Just to note a few recent examples, Jordan and Israel just established a joint emergency response team in preparation for a natural disaster. Dr. Bruria Adini, head of the collaborative team, hopes to one day bring the pilot program to the Palestinian territories, Egypt and Syria — envisioning concrete normalization of relations in the region. In addition, Israel also plans to construct a mega−solar plant in coordination with Egypt to supply alternative energy sources.

Moreover, Israel's contributions in the cultural realm are abundant. For example, nine Israelis have been awarded Nobel prizes, ranging from achievements in the promotion of peace, chemistry, literature, biology and economics. Tel Aviv's White City is composed of 4,000 Bauhaus−style buildings, and its architectural splendor is protected by its status as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. In a matter of a century, Hebrew has been revived from an ancient Biblical language to the spoken tongue and written vernacular. The first Prime Minister of Israel, David Ben−Gurion, devised a method to create a cultural melting pot within Israeli society by creating an Israeli Defense Force and a pluralistic education system that incorporate citizens from any background or heritage.

In understanding Israel today, one must return to the roots of the Zionist movement. Zionism originates from the national liberation struggle by the Jewish people who sought refuge in their historical homeland in the face of persecution, state−sponsored pogroms and ultimately, the calamity of the Holocaust. In 1947, the United Nations overwhelmingly approved the Partition Plan, thus enabling the State of Israel to be founded with the full backing of international law and the global community. Since its founding, Israel has absorbed more immigrants per capita than any other nation worldwide. A shocking three million immigrants have been integrated into Israeli society in the last 62 years. Zionism has always aimed to provide Jews from all corners of the world with a sense that they can find protection and refuge in their ancestral homeland, even implementing covert operations to rescue tens of thousands of Ethiopian Jews in the 1990s. The State of Israel will continue to fulfill its promise to provide a protective umbrella for the Jewish Diaspora worldwide, and for this reason, Israel's purpose continues to be not only relevant, but of pressing and critical importance. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. could not have prophetically depicted Israel better when he stated in 1968, "Israel is one of the great outposts of democracy in the world and a marvelous example of what can be done, how desert land can be transformed into an oasis of brotherhood and democracy." Daniel Bleiberg is a freshman who has not yet declared a major. He is the political vice president for Tufts Friends of Israel.

--

Daniel Bleiberg is a freshman who has not yet declared a major. He is the political vice president for Tufts Friends of Israel.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

16 comments Log in to Comment

Anonymous
Thu Mar 18 2010 11:53
Everyone knows Ibrahim plagiarized/forged his article, so who even cares if Daniel's article actually responded.
Anonymous
Thu Mar 18 2010 02:18
this stuff is straight out of the hasbara/birthright textbook...good attempt to "reframe the debate" but most people with even a modest understanding of the conflict won't be fooled by all of this. just because israel created the computer processor or whatever doesn't mean that they don't do some f'ed up stuff (like kicking those palestinians out of their house in east jerusalem last week). love israel but hate this stuff because it stupifies the debate.

and irt to bleibergs friend...
is there some magical economics formula where extra aid naturally accounts for all those achievements?? not surprising huh? haha ok freshman.

Observant
Wed Mar 17 2010 13:19
“Schuld” — it’s German for guilt. -- Ibrahim Khwaja

Der Judenstaat: It’s German for “The State of the Jews.” -- Daniel Bleiberg

Yeah. That doesn't sound like a response at all.

Anonymous
Tue Mar 16 2010 23:38
What's really interesting is that I recall this exact same "argument" being made during a high school model congress in which I introduced a resolution condemning Israel for human rights abuses and aggressive posturing. Literally no response was made to my faux-bill, just a long list of accomplishments of hardworking Israeli citizens who,I would imagine, have a wide range of opinions on the actions of their government.

So I wonder, does AIPAC or one of the other groups send out a little packet for school kids with a list of these talking points? Is this how they teach you to respond during Birthright trips? Defending the injustices of the Israeli government with non-sequitors like these is just as counter-productive and ignorant as justifying a rocket launched into a Jewish settlement with "They kick grandpa out back in '48!"

Arafat
Tue Mar 16 2010 22:37
No people are better at oppressing Arabs than Arabs.

Come to think of it, no people are better at oppressing people than Muslims.

Anonymous
Tue Mar 16 2010 12:56
very poorly written. Let's just hand the state over to Abbas, Daniel.
Anonymous
Tue Mar 16 2010 08:33
this is so embarrassing for you Daniel...
Jumbolaya
Tue Mar 16 2010 08:02
Yeah Daniel, you really should have written an actual response to that last article-- it wouldn't have even been hard.
Anonymous
Tue Mar 16 2010 01:32
Israel is not capable of providing a worldwide umbrella loddy dotty dah.
And the bbc provided an article last week stating Israel deports immigrant non-Jew women who give birth in Israel.
google news word search 'israel immigrants'

read asher ginzburg's 'truth from palestine'

Fans361
Tue Mar 16 2010 00:00
This article was not meant to be a response in any way whatsoever, and the Daily provided this incorrect title. The article was just meant to demonstrate Israel in a positive light.
Anonymous
Mon Mar 15 2010 22:59
A "response" is not exactly that. The ends do not justify the means. Just because Isreal is a successful country does not make it right for them to persecute others, no matter what form it takes. I will admit, the Arab nations are not exactly angles but for those who support Isreal blindly without taking notice of the injustices committed are equally part of the problem.
A wise fool
Mon Mar 15 2010 22:07
A pathetic and illogical response to the original article. Boy, how did you get into Tufts?
Anonymous
Mon Mar 15 2010 17:14
Who attempts to rebuke an article about the rise of fascism in Israel by saying how great the state is?
Anon
Mon Mar 15 2010 17:11
Jews in America are more pro-Israel than Israelies.

They also seem to only care about Israel and NOTHING ELSE.

Anonymous
Mon Mar 15 2010 13:37
I am very disappointed by the Daily's decision to publish this Op-Ed. First let me make clear that I take no issue with the viewpoints expressed by Mr. Bleiberg; I am quite pleased to see a sovereign Jewish state have so much success in its short history. However, this commentary is horrendous. Thanks for the one-sided propagandistic "opinion piece," but if I wanted to read a list of a handful of accomplishments by a particular nation, I am sure there's a Wikipedia page on that. This is nothing more than that– a list. This is not even a response to "McCarthyite Zionism." Though, I would believe it if I were told it is a response to "Please write up a non-cohesive list of accomplishments lacking a thesis that ignores all opposing viewpoints." When it was mentioned that 20 of the 22 Middle Eastern nations refuse to recognize Israel, I thought, "OK, here's where we see some good point-making in the editorial." But no. It was left at that, with a quick segue into another one of Israel's accomplishments. Can I know something about WHY those nations refuse to recognize Israel? Even if there was a counterargument presented that called those other Middle Eastern nations "pussies," I would have still loved to get another perspective on any of these issues. I learned nothing from this article. Nothing. Except maybe that Israel's first Olympic medal was in judo. Big deal.
Bleibergs Friend
Mon Mar 15 2010 12:54
Israel has accomplished more than other developing countries, but then again it does receive more aid than any other developing country hence the list of successes isn't surprising.

THERE'S STILL RAMPANT McCARTHYITE ZIONISM - CALLING PEOPLE ANTI-SEMITIC IF THEY DON'T AGREE

WITH ISRAEL'S OPPRESSIVE POLICIES IN REGARDS TO PALESTINIANS AND DARE I SAY ARABS AT LARGE.

You must be logged in to comment on an article. Not already a member? Register now

Log In