College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

An interview with Joe the Plumber

By Michael Bendetson

Print this article

Published: Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Updated: Tuesday, November 11, 2008

John McCain and Man

MCT

Every presidential election has distinct images and words that come to people’s minds when they reminisce. In 1960, it was the New Frontier. In 1980, it was Morning Again in America. In 2008, it was Joe the Plumber.

On a warm October afternoon, Joe asked Sen. Obama if his tax plan would cost him more and whether it would conflict with the American dream. Obama responded, “I think when you spread the wealth around, it’s good for everybody.” Joe quickly became a hero among conservatives for his courage and his honesty. In the third presidential debate, Joe the Plumber was mentioned 26 times, while the economy was mentioned 16 times and Iraq just 6 times. For the remainder of the campaign, Sen. John McCain and Gov. Sarah Palin represented themselves as the party of average people like Joe the Plumber. I shared a very nice phone conversation with Joe, during which he elaborated on his opinions.

Question: There has been some confusion amongst the media with regards to your name and occupation. Could you provide some clarification?

Answer: All right. Well, my name is Samuel J. Wurzelbacher. I go by [my] middle name Joseph and shorten it to Joe and have gone by that since I was born and have always been called Joe. With regards to my occupation, I was a plumber in the military for the United States Air Force. I used to teach plumbing in the military. A lot of times the licenses that are obtained in the military world do not transfer over into the civilian world.

There is also a little bit more to the story. I have a son who is 13 and have made sure that he was my number-one priority. Wherever my ex-wife traveled, I moved in order to be closer to my son. On my last move, I moved with my ex-wife from the state of Arizona to Ohio so my son and I could be together. I attended [plumbing] school for three-and-a-half years when the school went out of business. I had enough on-the-job training as far as time and service to master as a plumber … So I am a plumber. Am I licensed in the state of Ohio as a plumber? Absolutely not. I have tried to clear that up on a lot of radio and television stations.

Q: Could you please explain and elaborate on your encounter with Sen. Obama?

A: My son and I were playing football in the streets. All of a sudden, a crowd rushed by on the street. This was weird because usually you do not see that in the neighborhood. My son and his friend went to see what was going on and exclaimed that Barack Obama was here. I thought to myself that that was kind of cool. I had my mind made up for the most part [on] who I was voting for, but I still thought it was pretty amazing that Sen. Obama would come door to door talking to people.

As he started getting closer and closer to our house, I went over to my neighbor’s house to hear him. I heard some of the questions being asked. I am thinking that the questions being asked were quite silly. I thought what me and my friends had talked about actually asking a politician, and making him answer straightly; usually they have a problem with doing so. A week prior to this happening, my boss and I talked about me taking over the business, and what it would require for me to make that happen. Essentially, that is why that question was at the forefront of my mind. I went up to him and yelled, “Barack.” He looked and acknowledged me, and the crowd quickly parted for me. Immediately, I questioned him.

Q: Why do you and so many other Americans find the words “spread the wealth around” so troubling?

A: Well, I am fairly well read and have read Karl Marx’s work, and spread the wealth around is something that he mentions quite often. If you look up the word [socialism] in [Webster’s] Dictionary, the definition may not mention “spread the wealth,” but community work and sharing of goods all plays into it. Obama’s health-care plan is a very socialist experiment. [Obama’s plans] all revolve around socialism, and that’s what scares me about it.

Q: How did you feel when you became such an important factor in the final presidential debate and the campaign as a whole?

A: Initially, I thought it was completely absurd. I was glad that I could be used as a focal point to possibly bandy around some ideas, and maybe people would open their eyes to Obama’s socialist ideology. However, there were so many important issues to be discussed other than the “Joe the Plumber, Joe the Plumber.” [The debate] was absolutely ridiculous. After a while, I actually got tired of it. Not so much the “Joe the Plumber” I am tired of, but there are other issues that need to be discussed.

Q: To many Americans, you have become a symbol. What is it that you think that you represent?

A: Until I started receiving letters and phone calls, I did not try to represent anything. I am a lower-middle-class average guy who happens to have some common sense and wants a straight answer once in a while instead of a dissertation for an answer that when you’re done listening to it you’re wondering what the first word was. People identify with the fact that I give straight answers and ask for straight answers.

Q: You had the opportunity to campaign with Sen. John McCain in different areas of Ohio. What is your opinion with regards to Mr. McCain?

A: This is a tough question. [The McCain campaign] is trying to throw Sarah Palin under the bus. They are trying to allude to the fact that she is the reason that John McCain might have lost this election. That does not sit well with me. John McCain has not come out and said that Sarah Palin is an honorable woman and has not protected her. In terms of my opinion, he has my respect for being a war hero, and I told him that personally, but you got to get along to go along or go along to get along. Washington has been ingrained with that mentality.

Q: As a Republican, do you feel that Gov. Sarah Palin was the right vice-presidential selection?

A: Honestly, I think she shines too much. I think vice president no, president definitely. She has moral values. She has a record of change that ... John McCain had supposedly … Sarah was actually too big of a personality, too big of a person to be vice president.

Q: You have stated that a vote for Obama is a vote for “the death of Israel.” Could you please elaborate on what you meant by that claim?

A: I will elaborate and tell you how it came about. It was incredible ... We were at a pub, and out of nowhere a gentleman of Jewish descent appeared. He asked a very good question, and you could see the emotion on his face.

I was told that I did not have to answer his question because that would create quite the stir in the media’s eyes. If I am going to tout that I am going to be for the [average person], I absolutely had to answer the question. Being a Christian, I had to answer that. Obama has declared openly that he would meet with the president of Iran. The president of Iran has made many statements [about] turning Israel into a parking lot, which is the most disgusting thing that I have ever heard. The hate [from Iran] is there, and that’s factual and not rhetoric. They teach their children over there nursery rhymes about killing Jews. For a president to sit there and say that “I will meet with no terms and actually have terms dictated back to us” scares me.

Obama has been closely linked to many terrorists. Again this is not rhetoric; [these are] facts that the media did not want to bring out. Rasheed Kahalidi being amongst one of them, and there are nine or 10 others … These close ties scare me. As far as Obama getting into office with his ties and with the fact that he is willing to be dictated to by a known terrorist — [that] scares me for Israel. There are many more reasons, but those are the big ones.

Q: Considering the fact that your income is less than $250,000, will you not benefit more from an Obama administration than you would have under a McCain administration?

A: This is going to be a two part answer. The main thing I stand on is principle … For example, you have Michael and Donna. Michael is a good student and works hard to get a 4.0. Donna likes to party and go out and is pulling a 2.0. In Obama’s plan so to speak, you should just go to the dean and ask him to take away one point of Michael’s GPA and give it to Donna to make it “fair.” So now they both have 3.0. Isn’t that nice?

Once you start down the slope and set a precedent and say $250,000 is rich, eventually [the government is] going to decide $150,000 is rich. It’s all relative — if you live in New York or Los Angeles, $250,000 is not going to buy you a lot. Essentially, my reason is principle. If my buddy Jon is working harder than I am and he is making more money than I am, but I get the same amount as him, that’s just not right. That would not be fair. [Fair] is a big word the Democrats throw around, but they do not seem to understand what it means. Essentially, it comes back to stealing. I will not take someone else’s money that I did not work for.

Q: The Republican Party was dealt another devastating blow [on Nov. 4]. In your opinion, what do you feel the party needs to do in order to successfully regain control of the government? Also, what should disappointed conservatives like yourself do following the election?

A: The party should remember that they are conservative Republicans — that has been forgotten. They no longer hold to their ideals. They blow with the wind on just about every public opinion poll. So they are not right-wing; they are trying to show that they’re middle or even left-of-middle sometimes. You have to remember two years ago, the Democrats loved John McCain. That is not what this is about. If you’re a party, you have to stick to your ideals. The frontrunners in the Republican Party have definitely seem to forgotten that. Governor [Bobby] Jindal of Louisiana seems to have the right idea. We have got to get back to the grassroots of the Republican Party and not apologize for being conservative …

Q: There has been a tremendous amount of speculation about your political future. Web sites such as joewurzelbacher2010.com and others envision you challenging Rep. Marcy Kaptur [D-Ohio] for her seat in the House. Is there any truth to these rumors?

A: No. Marcy Kaptur is so entrenched in this area, I do not believe [anyone] could actually win against her. People around here for whatever reason love her to death. No one actually has ever come close in how many years to take her seat. Also, if I were to run for Congress, it [would be] a very big sacrifice. I would not take it lightly or as a sense of entitlement as some congressmen do. I would actually represent the people. I would be out there day to day, talking to people and finding out what is going on. I would really work hard.

The problem with that is I would not go along to get along in Congress. I would be loud, but I would be one voice among 435 people. I can do far more with this watchdog group that I am creating … the watchdog group is going to be essentially for the American people, Democrats or Republicans; I do not care. The Web site will remind the people in Washington that they are there to serve us …

Q: Various reports have also leaked the idea of you becoming a country musician. Is there any substance to this speculation?

A: No. I will dispel all the rumors I have heard. First, I will not be the new bachelor on ABC’s show. Second, I will not be a country music star. Most people pay me to stop singing — and not to sing. I will not be on a reality show; reality is what happens every day and not what happens when someone sticks a camera in your face.

--

Michael Bendetson is a freshman who has not yet declared a major.

Comments

116 comments
Jack
Wed Nov 19 2008 10:01
to 4mer ohioan:

Obama answered his question and that was the end...until McCain brought him up in the debates without doing any research to make Joe had told the truth...he hadn't. Of course the media got on it...Joe is a liar and profoundly ignorant. He's so ignorant that he doesn't even realize how most of the country views him...as a complete embarrassment.

carol
Wed Nov 19 2008 09:58
Joe the Plumber needs to go back to plumbing. He is totally irrelevant and not really bright. For starters, Obama's health care plan is NOT socialist. He should read up on it and compare it to Canada and other countries' socialist plans before he puts his foot in his mouth further.
laura
Wed Nov 19 2008 09:57
People in the GOP base are not making the connection to how undecideds viewed the whole Joe The Plumber roll out. Joe was treated fairly by Obama and even if he didn't like the answer, Obama gave him one that was honest. Joe was less than honest. McCain congratulated Joe for being "rich" twice during the debate and of course this sparked media scrutiny and it was discovered that Joe misrepresented his current situation, had been on welfare etc, his parents had etc....The base may have thought Joe was a great man, but the undecideds saw this as another example of John McCain's horrible judgment. When John McCain called Joe an "American Hero" he lost even more credibility. Joe is the classic example of someone who spouts of information that he knows very little about and votes against his own best interests. I believe he, in addition to Sarah Palin cost John McCain votes. The undecideds who eventually cast their votes for Obama in swing states were turned off by Joe's immediate embracing of rhetoric that he simply doesn't understand. He's a puppet who thinks he's a real boy.
Missy
Wed Nov 19 2008 09:57
Joe the Plumber, like Sarah Palin lacks smarts. Both just espouse soundbites that are specifically designed for the un-studied like them. That's fine, but we can't have them as leaders -- they simply lack the intellectual capacity make judgements and decisions on complex national and foreing policy issues. Sorry fans. For those who love their conservative social views, join their respective churches and enourage Joe and Sarah to become the church deacons -- that way you can follow them all you want without harming the rest of the country who needs smart leaders. Our country is too great to flush it down the toliet.
KCrouch
Wed Nov 19 2008 08:45
Mr. Bendetson has just outperformed almost every mainstream reporter who covered the campaign. He allowed himself to be the conduit for information to flow from his subject to the reader, interjecting clear questions to move the information along fully.
Kudos!
4mer Ohioian
Wed Nov 19 2008 03:44
Joe is your average guy who simply asked a presidential candidate, who came to Joe's neighborhood, a question and the liberals try to tear him apart. Talk about hypocrisy. I thought the Dem party was for the average guy.
Neil
Wed Nov 19 2008 00:17
By the way, turn-out was higher this year than in 2004, not lower.
Neil
Wed Nov 19 2008 00:15
Joe the Plumber is a not particularly intelligent or interesting individual who the McCain campaign thought might be a good symbol to showcase to try and win an election. That's all. He thinks the President-elect and the 66 million Americans who voted for him are Socialists and he's terrified of the scary black man becoming president, which I find to be pretty funny. He doesn't represent America. He doesn't represent Americans. He does probably represent the "dumb faction" of the Republican Party that has led to its downfall, to the chagrin of the many smart conservatives out there who know that the difference between socialism and capitalism is just a wee bit more than a 4.6% increase in the marginal tax rate applied to the top income bracket coupled with a reduction in the rate for lower income brackets.
mndasher
Tue Nov 18 2008 21:09
Chris - "Not, say, the fact an African American won it, or the hard fought, wildly-swinging primaries, or the amazingly high turnout of people choosing to take part in their nation's electoral process."

It of course was not an amazingly high turnout. A lower percentage turned out than in 2004.

Seems there is more common sense coming from Joe than from 95 percent of the politicians in this country.

Martin
Tue Nov 18 2008 19:01
When Joe says he is scared that Obama will start diplomatic talks with Iran , he actually going away from the real conservatism but to the neo conservatism of last 8-12 years . We were actually the party who hate War . We are the party which advocated against US becoming the worlds police .I think Joe should go back and brush up his conservative ideals and not confuse it with the policies of last 8-12 years that put our part in such a deep hole . And it was amusing to see that joe did not speak a single word on last few years when our part was in power . We need to go back to real conservatism but we should not confuse it with neo conservatism as Joe apparently does.
Chris
Tue Nov 18 2008 18:55
Yes Joe the Plumber was the touchstone image of the 2008 election.

Not, say, the fact an African American won it, or the hard fought, wildly-swinging primaries, or the amazingly high turnout of poeple choosing to take part in their nation's electoral process.

No, it's the bald, tax-evading, unlicensed plumber who chose to try to ambush one of the candidates because he's a member of the opposing party that will be the endearing image.

Riiiiiiiiiiiight.

W00t
Tue Nov 18 2008 18:12
Politico link from Ben Smith!!!
Darlene Beaune
Tue Nov 18 2008 15:53
I think joe the plumber is a fine, up-standing citizen and should go into politics. I say that because he gives a straight answer, and he looks you in the eye when he talks, and he cares about America, and the concerns of all the people of America. He is a good man, and some people should open their eyes and take a second look. God bless you Joe, I wish you well. Darlene Beaune
kimberly
Tue Nov 18 2008 14:17
I admire Joe, I believe that he represents a lot of americans. How dare you refer to him as dumb.
I wonder what you do for a living.....oh wait, you must have voted for NOBAMA....so your sitting around waiting for Joe's money to come your way
Karla
Tue Nov 18 2008 11:16
Great article and Joe has a fresh voice. I've joined his website and am looking forward to some great discussions.
Your name
Tue Nov 18 2008 03:40
I find it hard to believe that the answers to the interview were actually the words of Joke the Dumber. Give me a break. He needs to go back to herding turds.

This guy wouldn't know honesty if it bit him on the ass. Can you say wife beater (domestic abuse 2x), tax cheat, welfare recipiant (nothing socialist about that huh turd herder?) and all around dead beat. Now he has a book for sale. Do crayons come with it?

saigondash
Tue Nov 18 2008 03:37
I dind it hard to believe that the answers to the interview were actually the words of Joke the Dumber. Give me a break. He needs to go back to herding turds.
Sugarfoot
Tue Nov 18 2008 02:11
I am very proud that there are a few people out there like JOE,Sarah P. and John MC. are still out there. Thank our Good Lord and his word we know what to look for in a president. I am proud to be a Christian and I am very proud of our Words of Wisdom from the Holy Bible when it comes to what is good and what signs we should look for in a person to run a Christian found nation. My husband fought in two wars, WW2 and Korean war and spent many years in the service and he did it with pride and slowley but surely things are going down hill. These things I look for in a president, Moral Value, Anti-Abortion,Standing by Iseral and defending our security here in the US and abrode. It really hurts me to see people disrespect our American Flag, gay lifestyles which are an abomination to God, Killing sweet little unborn children who's fault they were created in the first place. Thank God for my mother who put me up for adoption when I was first born as opposed to taking my life. I was adopted and I found my biological mother about 1985. We had a good relation form then untill she died. She wanted me to have a better life than she could afford to give me what with her with 3 kids already at the time. I was raised in a Christian home and had a wonderful home and was blessed to find her and get close to her before she died. Now I have good christian Sisters and Brothers as my Biological Mother was a good Christian as well I was taught to go to church, respect our millitary, Believe The Bible as Gods words for then as well as now. Now it seems that every one wants to do away with the Pledge of Alegiance, and In God We Trust being taken off our money, No Ten Commandents, and to think that enough people voted in a prresident who won't even place his hand over his heart and face the US Flag. Won't wear a US Flag pin on his Lapel,and probably won't use the Holy Bible to swear in as our President or the US is absolutely stupid. All those Crooks that he hangs around with and he actually thinks he can sit down with our ennemies and make nice everything, He is CRAZY! The first thing you know they will be over here bomming up and killing people and I guess he will plan to be out of the country when that happens so he and his family will be safe. Everything I heard from him scared me. We don't even know if he is eligible to be president for sure. The birth certificate he did provide was not a original 1963 Birth certificate. His own grandmother stated that he was not born in the US. He won't give the names of those who donated to his campagn and no one checked out that Acorn business and all those fake registrations or any of those things. I gaurentee you that if It had been John McCain they would have done all kinds of investigations on him.We might not have had an election yet if they had researched his background and his dealings with the whole thing (Obama that is) I am plenty scared of Obama and his motives to be president of the USA. I can't understand why folks who voted him in didn't research all the stuff that came out about him, or why he didn't release all the information the other canadites did. And they ran down Sarah and she is a good Christian Person and I guess thats why they didn't like her, or Jealousy. I guess her morals were to good for most people. We are not raciest either. His color made no difference to us but his background and dealings sure did. I noticed that his taking form the rich went form 250,000 down to 125,000. and it may come down to people on social security before he gets out. He may make seniors pay taxes on their Social Security before all is said and done. Sure if I way a illigal person and he was going to give me a drivers License and Health Care even though I didn't come here legally I would vote for him to. But thats not fair to us or the ones who came here through a legal process. We have been giving SS benifits to babies born here to illeagel parents who's residence is out of the country and SS to folks who came over here and brought their parents who were Seniors and rewarded them with SS income who never paid into Social Security here in their lifetime. No wonder they say Social Security is going broke as well as all the other hand outs we are giving folks like that now. I Pray for America and hope the Lord watches over us during this next four years. I garentee you that folks are not doing as God would have them do. Yes he loves all his children, but he hates gay life styles,He made Adam and Eve and not Adam and Steve. It plainly says in the bible that is wrong. People has got away form the word of God and America may pay for it. I wonder if that is why California is having so many fires and destroying so many homes, All of Holliwood is corupt and maby he is trying to wake folks up. Sorry for so much venting but I am really worried where all this is headed. We"ll see. Only God can save this country if this guy is not what he claims to be .
A p
Fri Nov 14 2008 20:50
I really enjoyed reading this interview. I cannot believe the paper managed to get an interview with this guy. I cant say that I agree with him, but this is still pretty cool.
JR
Thu Nov 13 2008 01:54
I should mention that the article was very good and it was interesting to see Wurzelbacher picked for an interview. And indeed, like he said, real conservatism has basically vanished from the Republican Party. However, part of real conservatism involves having a sensible foreign policy, which involves negotiating peace instead of trying to brutally force it by starting wars (what should be feared is not Obama talking to Iran, but rather the prospect of him starting an undeclared, preventive war with Iran), as well as refraining from spending money you do not have. There's also the matter of actually following the Constitution and having the Congress declare war like it is supposed to. With none of this, you do not have real conservatism. You have a government out of control. This is what is sorely lacking from what Wurzelbacher is saying.






log out