Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

I'm a feminist, but…

Published: Thursday, February 5, 2009

Updated: Saturday, February 7, 2009 21:02

Feminism. It has been blamed for everything from destroying the family to killing chivalry to women drinking more alcohol to hook-up culture. Feminists have been antagonized as fat, ugly, hairy, bra-burning, man-hating lesbians; these enduring stereotypes have been manufactured by the mass media to discredit feminists. These stereotypes keep some women at bay from identifying themselves as feminists.  Time magazine in 1998 even questioned whether or not feminism was dead.

On the contrary, feminism is far from dead or irrelevant. These days, feminist statements are often disguised behind "I'm not a feminist, but…" (I'm not a feminist, but I believe men and women should have equal rights. I'm not a feminist, but I think that women deserve to get the same pay as men do for the same jobs.) People who say that may not know that they are feminists or may be intentionally shying away from the label of "feminist."

I did not know that I was a feminist until my senior year of high school when I took a feminist theory class. Before that I had never thought twice about feminism, but the class opened my eyes. I learned about what feminism is by learning about what it is not. It is not a female supremacist ideology that ugly women who cannot find boyfriends or husbands embrace to make themselves feel better. It is not a brainwashing cult that tells women to leave their husbands and their children. It is not just Ally McBeal's or the Spice Girls' cheers of "Giiiiiiiiiiiirl Power!" It is not just for women. The meaning of feminism varies from person to person, but in its most basic form, feminism is the belief that men and women are equal. For me, feminism is a way to examine and challenge the dominant power structures in society and the ways that different forms of oppression (racism, sexism, classism, heterosexism, ableism, etc.) intersect to maintain the status quo.

It's frustrating to hear the old "I'm not a feminist, but…" because feminism is still so pertinent and important in our lives. Women earn 77 cents to the male dollar -- so much for the Equal Pay Act of 1963, which was passed by Congress to put an end to wage discrimination based on gender. Rape wasn't declared a war crime until June 2008. Violence against transgender and transsexual people remains largely ignored, and the Equal Rights Amendment, a proposed amendment to the Constitution that provides for equal rights under the law regardless of gender, has yet to be passed.

We still need feminism when every Election Day in November, states try to pass laws that may threaten a woman's right to her own body. We still need feminism when female politicians who run for office are judged by their looks instead of their policies. We still need feminism when women may feel uncomfortable or unsafe walking down the street because of catcalling or other forms of sexual harassment. We still need feminism when classmates, friends, family or even we ourselves are sexually assaulted or raped and are afraid to come forward because of the fear that we will not be believed or will be blamed. We still need feminism when teenagers are taught nothing about sex in schools except not to have it, and consequently, many young women have unintended pregnancies.

Some "I'm not a feminist, but…" people have told me that they are hesitant to readily identify themselves as feminists because they want to avoid labeling themselves. While I do understand that viewpoint and see how categories can be very imposing and restrictive (look at our binary gender categories), I feel that by saying "I'm not a feminist, but…" is making a concession to the dominant paradigm. It's sort of like saying, "Yes, I have progressive values and believe in X, Y and Z, but I know that you'd disapprove, and it's socially unacceptable in your eyes for me to be open about my beliefs, so I won't align myself with those politics." Saying "I'm not a feminist, but women should not have to pay for their own rape kits" is almost like saying "I'm not an environmentalist, but people should really turn off the lights and unplug appliances when not in use." Prefacing a feminist thought with "I'm not a feminist, but…" makes it seem as though one is apologizing for having those thoughts, when in reality, what is there to apologize for? If you're a feminist, don't be ashamed of it. If you're a feminist, don't deny it. If you're a feminist, say it.

--

Tiffany Lam is a sophomore majoring in Women's Studies.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

11 comments Log in to Comment

Anonymous
Tue Mar 30 2010 23:52
Thankfully almost all of you profess to be feminists and not writers because not one of you can write. Tufts?
brent
Fri Mar 26 2010 17:56
Labels are often misleading, and people should shy away from them. The term "feminist" has existed in our society for a long time, has been developed by other people, and is interpreted by other people according to their own understanding. Someone who supports gender equality, but is not aware of the ideas and agendas of different members of the feminist movement should not call themselves a "feminist" because, by doing so, they may inadvertently advertise something they do not support. In your article, you cite laws that limit a woman's right to her own body as one of the offenses against women that occurs today. Are you referring to abortion? You also call yourself a feminist. Someone who supports gender equality, but opposes abortion, would do themselves a disservice to label themselves a "feminist" in a response to this article, because that label might be interpreted as support for legalizing abortion. I see no contradiction in the sentence: "I'm not a feminist, but I support gender equality. I just do not know what the term 'feminist' completely entails." People should always be hesitant to accept a label. If you are ignorant of feminist literature, don't be a feminist!
FeministReview.org
Sat Feb 14 2009 23:13
The reasons one may say "I'm not a feminist, but..." are much more complicated than what you have presented here. What about all of the women of color, queers, trannies, working class women, etc who have been ignored, backstabbed, or tokenized by the feminist movement? Sometimes it's not about feeling shame of negative labeling. Sometimes it is about self-preservation.
Your name
Mon Feb 9 2009 23:31
Bravo!
bryony1
Mon Feb 9 2009 22:00
A nameless person wrote: "There is not collective discrimination against women, and all of your complaining about it will only create an issue, not solve one."

How old are you? 14? 15? Well, chronological age doesn't really matter; it's mental age that counts, and mental age is comprised of knowledge and understanding that there are cultural traditions that are disgusting and unfair. One of the worst is denying the existence of bigotry against women in every facet of our lives. There excellent documentaries and books and blogs and websites devoted to the facts of discrimination against women, which feminism is trying to end. Educate yourself, and start by reading this article again. It tells it like it is. The problem has existed for many centuries. It is NOT being created right now.

Paul
Sun Feb 8 2009 22:06
You wrote: "Prefacing a feminist thought with "I'm not a feminist, but…" makes it seem as though one is apologizing for having those thoughts, when in reality, what is there to apologize for? If you're a feminist, don't be ashamed of it. If you're a feminist, don't deny it. If you're a feminist, say it."

I'm in total agreement. I AM a feminist. Period.

Thanks!

Ilana
Sat Feb 7 2009 23:56
Kylie: a book you might enjoy is one called "The Fire This Time". It's on third wave feminism, a compilation of essays written primarily for our generation (I was born in 1989). Real feminists don't hide behind complex ideology and theory; they get out there and change the world. Real feminists- and real *women*- don't reject anyone who wants to join the struggle.
Don't be afraid to voice your views: they are important, even if they frighten others. You are important. We all are.
Your name
Sat Feb 7 2009 23:55
Kylie: a book you might enjoy is one called "The Fire This Time". It's on third wave feminism, a compilation of essays written primarily for our generation (I was born in 1989). Real feminists don't hide behind complex ideology and theory; they get out there and change the world. Real feminists- and real *women*- don't reject anyone who wants to join the struggle.
Don't be afraid to voice your views: they are important, even if they frighten others. You are important. We all are.
Your name
Sat Feb 7 2009 23:52
There is not collective discrimination against women, and all of your complaining about it will only create an issue, not solve one.
one of the old ones
Sat Feb 7 2009 23:42
I became a feminist in 1971 (age 18) after reading the Female Eunuch by Germaine Greer. At the time it came out this book was an international sensation. It was outright revolutionary and it changed my life forever. I fought for the right to legal abortions and facilitated consciousness raising groups in California and Oregon. At the beginning (late 60's - early 70's), feminism was for all women. But, after Kate Millet came out as a lesbian it encouraged other lesbian women to come out as well. So the movement was split between straight and gay women - and then women of color started complaining that feminism was nothing more than a white women's movement and there was another split, then the split between women who chose to have kids and women who chose to have abortions. Then, women philosophers started arguing about whether women should be Marxists or anarchists . . . and then, and then, and then. By the early '80s I was so tired of the arguments I dropped out. I have never called myself a feminist since. I think women have to go through their own experience with feminism and take what works and flip off what doesn't. What's important is being a strong, independent, freedom loving individual - if feminism gets you there great, if not, try something else.
Kylie
Sat Feb 7 2009 21:41
I tend to say "I'm not a feminist, but..." because I'm afraid of real feminists.
In my own mind I do consider myself a very strong feminist, but the feminist community is so harsh on anyone claiming to be a feminist who doesn't understand all their esoteric concepts and lingo that I shy away from calling myself a feminist in order not to be pounced upon. Yes, in the strict sense of the word, I am a feminist, but I am not a female supremacist. I like the term "equalist." Yet I used that term on a feminist website and found myself completely ostracised. I find my humanist concepts easier to explain and live with. And being a humanist is about rights and equality, which kind of comes back into being a feminist anyway.

You must be logged in to comment on an article. Not already a member? Register now

Log In