Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Rally goers: We will not be silenced

Published: Friday, April 17, 2009

Updated: Friday, April 17, 2009 14:04


Around 200 people gathered on the Tisch Library patio and steps midday yesterday, decrying hate crimes and bias incidents against all groups and demanding that the administration take substantive action to prevent racism and hatred from continuing to pervade the Hill.

Under a sunny sky, students, administrators, faculty members and others spoke against the prevalence of discrimination, stereotyping of and biases against Asian-Americans and other minority groups. A large percentage of attendees wore red clothing to mark the rally, which had the goal of raising awareness of what many presenters said were often seemingly invisible acts of hate.

An altercation in the early-morning hours last Thursday between members of the Korean Students Association (KSA) and a freshman spurred the organization of the event. The administration is conducting a judicial investigation into the alleged bias incident, which many rally participants yesterday labeled a hate crime.

"If this was truly an isolated incident, we wouldn't have given it too much thought," said Jenny Lau, the incoming president of the Asian American Alliance, during a speech yesterday. Lau, a junior, explained the rally's aims and said the incident was representative of a much greater problem.

"As students, we have the right to feel respected and safe on ... campus," she said, calling on the administration to include the study of Asian-Americans in the curriculum. "The Asian-American voice is only one example of many voices of people who have been ... marginalized."

Last Thursday morning, a drunken freshman shouted racial slurs at a group of 13 Korean students practicing in the main lounge of Lewis Hall for their weekend culture show, KSA members at the scene said; the freshman told the Daily in a statement that he yelled obscenities, but he did not mention uttering racial epithets or being drunk.

The racially charged alleged remarks came after violence broke out between the KSA members and the freshman, according to KSA members. Both parties said the other side started the scuffle.

The Daily is withholding the freshman's name because the administration has not taken any action against him.

Yesterday's rally did not focus primarily on the details of the event itself, but rather on the wider implications of what many speakers called hate incidents that occur too frequently.

KSA Co-President Young Jeong spoke on behalf of two members of his group who were in the Lewis Hall lounge on Thursday morning.

"'F--k you ... Go back to your country,'" he told attendees the freshman had said that night. "Imagine these words being thrown at you."

"We are not here to ask for retaliation or revenge or any kind of punishment," Jeong, a senior, said. "We are here to raise awareness ... to give voice to those who have been silenced."

Senior Lecturer of American Studies Jean Wu denounced certain online discourse, including comments on TuftsDaily.com, that suggested rally organizers and supporters are "addicted" to reacting to bias incidents and hate crimes, she said.

The remarks the freshman allegedly made, she explained, cut deep.

"For Asian-Americans, these words are not the garden-variety putdown," she said.

University President Lawrence Bacow's chief of staff, Michael Baenen, attended the meeting in Bacow's place.

"Expressions of bias are insidious ... they are always hurtful, they erode community and they are not what we want Tufts to be about," he said. "I don't think any of us, especially those in Ballou, thinks we are where we want to be."

But later during yesterday's event, Lau chastised Bacow for sending a representative in his place and Baenen for not using a stronger term than "bias."

Reached later for comment, Baenen said that Bacow had been on the Boston campus attending meetings with overseers of the School of Medicine. Those meetings had been planned months in advance, Baenen added.

Boston City Councilor Sam Yoon, the city's first Asian-American councilor, spoke at the rally, too. He said that he had experienced hateful speech when he was on the campaign trail.

"This is not an isolated incident," said Yoon, who is running for mayor of Boston. "It's something that's endemic in our society."

Asian-Americans have long had to face stereotypes of them as passive, defenseless members of society, although other groups have had to endure hate, as well, Yoon said.

"When injustice or racial hatred happens to one of us," he said, "it happens to all of us."

Seniors Sofia Nelson and Jen Bailey told the crowd about similar incidents that have occurred in the past few years, saying the fact that they were attending yet another rally against bias was disappointing.

Nelson also railed against what she called "unacceptable" media coverage of the incident, particularly calling out Daily columnist and junior Will Ehrenfeld's Tuesday article, "Stuff Tufts People Like: Alleging bias." She criticized the piece in an op-ed she co-authored with senior Sarah Robbins that appeared in yesterday's Daily.

Nelson expressed anger at a decision by Daily editors to insert the word "allegedly" at certain points in her article that dealt with the particulars of last Thursday morning's events.

"Nothing about this incident is alleged," Nelson said yesterday. "I know what happened."

Two students delivered spoken-word pieces during the latter half of yesterday's presentation, poetically expounding on race and stereotypes in America. A Harvard University lecturer and a lawyer from the University of Massachusetts Boston also spoke.

Dean of Undergraduate Admissions Lee Coffin, who delivered a short speech, said that he was proud of yesterday's rally, even though it came during the biannual diversity-focused Telescope event that yesterday brought admitted students to campus.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

Your name
Tue Apr 21 2009 10:51
The comments on here are disappointing.
Obviously Tufts and like institutions can be little sheltered bubbles, but honestly, it doesn't make discrimination any less real, just more insidious.
There are systematic ways, including the barrage of feedback such as most of yours in these comments, in which certain issues are and are not up for discussion. Shutting down experiences with discrimination is silencing...
The rally isn't just to complain. It's partly a message to the administration that they better not just sweep this and like incidents under the rug. Additionally, there is a healing process in such rallying and coming together with ally communities.
And the finger isn't at one person... when you ask "who" is the culprit, the silencer?
Even the student who read some of his own slam poetry implicates all people in the production of division and hate... obviously, a rally will not suffice to end racism. also, racism will not end... but we do want to constantly engage in ways that may help us create spaces that make more sense... where people can simply be, rather than be objectified, profiled, targeted for illegimate purposes.

i'm not saying each speaker at the rally made sense.
but for those who end simply at criticizing one of them or the other... why not also ask questions about the bigger picture.
as a human... if ur offering criticism... make it constructive... if derision is your purpose... why are u so intent on denouncing such rallies? people don't do it all the time... esp. Asian Americans don't do this all the time. for every huge number of racist incidents, there might be one... two (?) rallies...
i'm glad students spoke out and send out the message that we will not put up with hate, that acts of hate are not to be brushed off, but addressed.
and it's key how the administration responds because that is key to whether or not the "we will not be silenced" stance needs to be assumed or shed...
no, we can't achieve harmony simpy through a rally--
but much less could we if we don't realize the extent and the depth of racism.
it's got deep roots and if we don't start talking about it more... acknowledging it more...
we're not gonna realize that instead of diversity making America rich, it's making it fraught with ethnic tensions.
i'm not proofreading this... but i hope u get my gist.

i think we should all listen to each other.

even though i felt like labeling you all internet trolls...
i realized you're most likely just other tufts students...
and that knowing these opinions are key to a debate.

if me and you can be reconciled... that's a start.

anon
Tue Apr 21 2009 00:10
@Dan: "It's pitiful what kinds of "causes" people are choosing to rally behind these days and put precious amounts of time and effort into. Whatever happened to being the bigger man and ignoring the opinions of the people whose opinions don't deserve the time of day?"

because racism OBVIOUSLY isn't important enough of a cause for you? the fact that he threatened to KILL the korean american students isn't important enough? obviously you need to get out of your little privileged, sheltered bubble and recognize that this is the kind of shit that gets people killed. look up Vincent Chin and then tell me that the KSA is being "overly sensitive."

Indeed.
Mon Apr 20 2009 23:28
It's interesting that his issue has served to further alienate the Asian-American community from the rest of the school. Rather than turning this into a kum-by-yah type of thing, they chose to very aggressively make it an us-versus-them situation, going as far as to demand that alums stop donating to the school until MANDATORY sensitivity training be administered to the entire school.

All faux-outrage aside, the Asian community at this school is more self-segregating than any other group. Taking the actions of one drunk person and applying his faults to the rest of us is absurd and more than unreasonable, it's downright divisive.

And for the record, if these mandatory education sessions actually happen, I won't show up. Because I'm not a racist, and I have better things to do.

Your name
Sun Apr 19 2009 16:18
making a racist joke while drunk is not comparable to spitting on someone. At the very least jokes are meant to make you laugh, not degrade you. additionally, do we have to wait until someone is in the hospital to act? why can't we fight for change before worse incidents happen? it is not about picking on a white guy from a boring state. no one is pointing fingers and saying all perpetrators of racism are white. I, for one, definitely do not think that. although I don't agree with the petition to withhold money, I do agree with the petition to raise awareness on campus. At the very least, students should feel accepted/safe and have a place to turn to when encountering these situations.
Your name
Sun Apr 19 2009 11:41
*embarrassing*

so excited for prospective students to come to tuftsdaily.com

Your name
Sun Apr 19 2009 09:37
Tufts is what it is compared to other elite Mass. colleges because of its occasionally bemused administration and its apparent policy of admitting only the most thin-skinned, attention-starved applicants it can find as students. Grow up-- this incident is being handled as it should be, the community is against any sort of race/sex/anti-plantloverism there is, and still folks are out gnashing their teeth and speaking in tongues about the big boogeyman that is THE WHITE GUY FROM A BORING STATE that is intent on keeping them down. Christ.
Your name
Sun Apr 19 2009 01:11
While I agree that what happened was terrible and no one should have to experience what those KSA students had to, I think that this whole issue has gone WAY too far. When I heard about the rally I thought "Oy, is that really necessary?" but figured that voices needed to be heard on the issue. However, when I got an invite to sign a petition about the issue, I realized that an incident that, while very hurtful, should not have been made to be such a big deal has become completely blown out of proportion. I agree that the incident was racist, but the kid was drunk and people do stupid things when they are intoxicated! Not that it is an excuse, but really? If I had a rally every time one of my drunken friends made a Jewish joke or a New Jersey joke, no one would ever be be to walk up by the library! My heart is with the Korean students who were unfortunately involved in this incident, but I do not think that I can help them continue their "campaign" against racism any further.
shy sophomore
Sat Apr 18 2009 23:34
this is just for sophia: thank you. what you said mattered to lots of people, even if we aren't the ones ranting on this website. thanks.
White Elephant
Sat Apr 18 2009 19:33
What a sad display of ad hominem, or should I say ad homosexual, attacks. Don't your professors teach you that this is a poor form of argument?

The drunken frat boy and the administration's response are a disgrace on Tufts. Now we all know why it continues to be an also-ran amongst Massachusetts colleges, bad quality students and incompetent administrators. Whom do you protect and support a drunk, ignorant, racist, and aggressive student, or the entire communities he offended?

The decision is quite simple.

The Decider
Sat Apr 18 2009 16:15
Yeah, Sofia is the campus's token militant lesbian. You know how Spiderman has a Spidey sense? Well Sofia has something similar that alerts her to oppression wherever it occurs. Investigation? Due process? Super Sophie has no use for these, for she sees all, hears all, and knows all. Bow down, mortals.

By the way, for those of you who don't know who Sofia Nelson is, I don't think all of these Jesse Jackson/Al Sharpton/Klansman comparisons do her justice...think of Janeane Garofalo with a buzz cut. You with me? Now give her a bad temper and make her retarded. Almost there...

Sofia the Omniscient
Sat Apr 18 2009 13:17
I tend to think Sofia Nelson is less Al Sharpton and more what a KKK member would be like were he turned into a lesbian. Still angry and hateful, still bigoted, still enjoys rallying and bullying others, still has her little cronies to congratulate her every step of the way, and still feeling like she's doing the right thing.
VanishingSonThao
Fri Apr 17 2009 23:13
Next time get someone more credible than Sam Yoon. That's like getting a combination of both Louis Farrakhan and Uncle Tom to come speak at an NAACP rally.
Rob C
Fri Apr 17 2009 21:33
If any of you ever paid attention to In The SACK, you'll know that individualistic models of society, like the way so many people want to believe the United States is, are unrealistic ways of explaining actual behavior. The fact that society in and out of Tufts isn't your fault, abc, and it isn't mine. Even the drunk kid in the incident with KSA is not entirely to blame for his comments. But he is responsible to an extent, and so are we, in a social system where divisiveness, prejudice, and ignorance remain. We are all responsible for participating and taking such a system for granted. We have to all think about where we are located in this social system, where others are, how to empathize with them, and use our abilities to help solve racism once and for all.
abc
Fri Apr 17 2009 19:52
KSA has every reason to be upset at what transpired, and initially it made sense that they would rally. However, I resent how they are blaming Tufts as a group for the actions of one individual. KSA has received an overwhelming amount of support (as they should have), yet the Tufts community is being blamed for an 'endemic' problem of racism!?!

I refuse to be made feel guilty for something I did not do or support.

kenny
Fri Apr 17 2009 18:12
whoa, there kids. whatever happened to 'give peace a chance'? enough already-it's spring time- go outside and enjoy yourselves. sitting in your dorm rooms fuming about nonsense is getting nobody nowhere. everyone is entitled to freedom of speech but this comment board has become an arena for personal insults-precisely the kind of negativity that triggered this whole mess. has anyone seen the south park episode called "Cartman's funny hate crime"? download it. smile.
It's you who needs to grow up!
Fri Apr 17 2009 14:43
Certain words, especially racial slurs, have a history of brutal / inhuman violence that follow them and that is why they cannot be accepted in any environment, even the "real world" that you deadbeats think you know and understand so well. Why don't you take a decent course on Asian American history and you'd know what I'm talking about. Oh wait, there isn't one and it's not like you're going to research it yourself! And thus you live in your ignorant bliss. Bravo! You should all give yourselves a round of applause for being ignorant. Seriously, what would you have preferred? After someone spat on your face and vomited racists words at you, would you stand still and take it like some submissive dog or voice your opinion against it? Seriously. You people make me sick!
Your name
Fri Apr 17 2009 14:30
"I can't wait until these kids move into the real world. Let me share a secret with you: Tufts is a pretty idyllic place compared to anywhere else. Appreciate it while you can."
Let me share a secret with you: we know! Thanks for speaking on behalf of the real world but we've been there too. And I've learned from the real world that voices of dissent won't always be seen as being appreciative of a community and being a responsible member within it to keep it that way or further advance the community.
Dan
Fri Apr 17 2009 13:17
This is complete bullshit! People are giving this drunk kid way to much credit, and making a mountain out of a molehill. Let's grow the hell up! You can't just go crying to mommy and daddy when somebody calls you a bad name, especially if some person is just being a drunk moron and not thinking clearly (even if, as I've heard, that person is a deuchebag to begin with).

It's pitiful what kinds of "causes" people are choosing to rally behind these days and put precious amounts of time and effort into. Whatever happened to being the bigger man and ignoring the opinions of the people whose opinions don't deserve the time of day?

Thanks KSA and all those people who rallied behind this for making the rest of us Tufts kids look like a bunch of sissy, ignorant, pathetic, selfish whiners. You should be ashamed of yourselves!

Your name
Fri Apr 17 2009 12:15
**First sentence supposed to read "Sophia Nelson is the gay female equivalent..."
Your name
Fri Apr 17 2009 12:14
Sophia Nelson is the most the gay female equivalent of Al Sharpten and Jesse Jackson. Somehow she becomes prominently involved in an event that is not about her and then makes arrogant, accusatory statements. Grow up Sophia.

You must be logged in to comment on an article. Not already a member? Register now

Log In