Injuries, inexperience prove too much to overcome
August 31A 2-6 season ending in five consecutive losses is not exactly the way Tufts' football team hoped to finish this season, but that's the way things look after the dust settled on Saturday's 27-0 thrashing by the Middlebury Panthers. Seventeen players from that squad will be lost to graduation, and some team members see the disappointing finish as a poor sendoff for the veterans. "The only thing that I was disappointed about this season was for the seniors," junior cornerback Evan Zupancic said. "If it was my senior year, I wouldn't want to go out like that." Other team members put a more positive spin on the season. "We had a really good group of seniors," sophomore quarterback Todd Scalia said. "A lot of guys really worked hard, and we fought in every game. The season was really impressive in that sense." Regardless of the team's final record, Tufts, which fielded an offense featuring several first-year starters, did not enter the season with the expectation of turning many heads. At best, the team had its sights set on topping last year's .500 record after the graduation of quarterback Chris Fahy and wide receiver Jon Troy. Meeting such expectations seemed likely in the opening stages of the season, after early wins over Bates and Bowdoin propelled Tufts to a 2-1 beginning. The Jumbos peaked with a 27-23 win over Bowdoin in week three, garnering a season high in points. In the final six games, an offense that hoped to mature as the season wore on could only average nine points a contest. That wasn't helped by injuries that sidelined fullback Jon Rodgers, quarterback Scott Treacy, running back Brian Holmes, and a good portion of the young offensive line. Rodgers, a senior starting for the first time, was lost for good against Bowdoin, while Holmes sat just one game but played with a bothered hamstring all season long. Treacy, meanwhile, never saw the game time he may have expected after backing up Fahy last year. After getting benched for the opener because of a hamstring problem, the sophomore replaced Scalia in the second game but threw just 12 passes, five of which were completions. Treacy's injury was re-aggravated in the third game, essentially ending his season. With Rodgers out and Holmes hurting, an offense expected to run first had to change its game plan midseason, and the untested Scalia was given freer reign to throw the ball. His completion and yardage numbers picked up, but along with that came more mistakes, excepting an interception-free performance against Middlebury on Saturday. Holmes, despite finishing with 620 yards rushing, did not have a touchdown all season, and the Jumbos didn't rush for a score at all after sophomore Chuck McGraw's two running touchdowns in week three. "At the beginning of the season, I thought we were going to be a contender to compete for the NESCAC Championship," Zupancic said. "But then we were just stricken with injuries and had third or fourth string guys in there." Scalia saw the stretch run differently. "Lots of guys stepped it up near the end," he said. "We really evolved as a team even though our record didn't show it." But that evolution certainly didn't occur on defense. While injury and inexperience hampered both the offense and the defense, something went awry on the defensive end of the field midway through the season. Perhaps the team's biggest feat was limiting Amherst, one of the NESCAC's three champions, to just eight points, its fewest point total of the season. But other than that, the Jumbos struggled the rest of the way down the stretch, as a once nationally-ranked run defense malfunctioned against some of the NESCAC's better rushers. Williams freshman Michael Hackett notched 148 yards rushing in the Jumbos' 21-10 Homecoming loss, Amherst's Okey Ugwonali ran for 151 yards a week later, and Middlebury's Bryan Sanchez broke the defense down all day long on Saturday on his way to 215 yards and three touchdowns. In between the losses to Amherst and Middlebury was a 28-14 defeat at the hands of Colby and sophomore sensation Pat Conley. The quarterback, who set the NESCAC all-time record this season with 1,996 yards passing, threw for 256 yards and three touchdowns against the Jumbos. Conley stunned a Tufts defense that had a somewhat easier time against the pass this season in the wake of several key quarterback graduations across the conference. The defensive problems could spell trouble for next season. If 2000 marked the rebuilding of Tufts' offense, 2001 might do the same for its defense. Linemen Pete Distaulo and Everett Dickerson, linebackers Joe McLean and Mike Marino and defensive back Jeff Karacz, among others, will be lost. A young nucleus led by Zupancic, who topped the squad in interceptions, lineman Caleb Hudak and defensive back Greg Devine will have a lot of weight on its shoulders next year. Zupancic, though, is confident that the returning players will translate into a better team in '01. "We're pretty much pulling back the entire offense," he said. "And we also have a base of returners on defense. It's not like we're going to be throwing in guys who have no experience. We'll be ready to compete with anyone in the league." The offense will return essentially everyone except hybrid defensive back/halfback Holmes and senior wideout Brett Cicchillo. McGraw was limited for most of the season but will likely be the team's top rushing option next year, while a plethora of young receivers, including freshman Matt Cerne and sophomore Bryan Pitko, impressed sporadically and will likely form the core of next year's offense. An offensive line decimated by injuries brings back everybody, including junior Mike Willey and sophomores Garret Roberts and Andy Dickerson. But this season's constant rotation on the line may have robbed some of the young players of a much-needed year of experience. Perhaps the biggest question to be asked about next season is the same one that surrounded the team a few months ago: who will start at quarterback? While Treacy's opportunities were limited and Scalia picked up his consistency towards the end of the year, nothing is certain for 2001. Uncertainties still abound for the Jumbos, and they'll have hurdles to get over next season if they are to avoid a fate similarly dismal to this year. A once-powerful defense will have to cope with vital losses, and an offense with a year of experience under its belt nonetheless remains unproven. Moreover, this NESCAC season was marked by an abundance of conference powerhouses and conference disappointments, but little in between. Climbing the NESCAC ladder to the upper echelon of teams likely remains at least a couple of seasons away. Still, the team feels that there is nowhere to go but up. "Good leaders are always hard to replace," Scalia said. "But next year our offense is only losing one guy and if everyone works hard we should do well." "Most great teams have to take a few years to build up before they peak and then continue to peak," Zupancic said. "It'll be hard to do worse than last season."

