We are writing to respectfully ask that voters across Somerville vote “no” on Question 3.
This ballot question does nothing to constructively help Palestinians and instead hurts our neighbors — and our city itself. Implementing the question is illegal, sows division in our community and diverts attention and resources from urgent issues facing our city.
It’s illegal. The basis of Question 3 is discriminatory and has even been deemed likely illegal by the deputy city solicitor because it intrudes on federal commerce power and may encroach on local businesses’ First Amendment rights. With the rise in antisemitism nationwide, this ballot question raises deep concerns among many of the Jewish neighbors who call Somerville home. It would unfairly discriminate, invite lawsuits and waste city resources.
It sows division in our community. Signature collectors have allegedly been overheard describing the ballot measure as a divestment from Jewish businesses. At a time when the inclusive and welcoming nature of our country is being challenged, is this what we want Somerville to be known for?
It diverts attention and resources from urgent local issues. Somerville families are struggling to keep up with the rising cost of living. Immigrants from all walks of life and countries of origin are being deported from our streets. Our schools and health care are at risk from federal budget cuts. Our local government should not be focused on foreign policy questions that turn neighbors against neighbors — and that make it harder to address these pressing problems.
Supporters of the ballot measure claim they are only asking Somerville to boycott companies that “engage in business that sustains Israel’s apartheid, genocide and illegal occupation of Palestine.” But that’s just the tip of the iceberg. The national boycott movement also targets construction equipment manufacturers like Volvo; tech companies like Dell, Microsoft, Google, Apple and Intel; Teva Pharmaceuticals (maker of a generic Narcan); Amazon; Disney; McDonald’s; Coca-Cola. The list goes on.
Supporters of the ballot measure are already attempting to block a new partnership between Massachusetts and the Israeli medical center Sheba — a collaboration aimed at helping startups develop lifesaving innovations in radiology, stroke treatment, cancer care, heart surgery and more.
The language of the ballot measure is so vague and broad that the city might be unable to work with anyone affiliated with these companies. Students could lose their HP Chromebooks. The city might not be able to rebuild the Winter Hill Community School, repair our streets or build new bike lanes. The city could be forced to operate without Microsoft, Google or Apple technology — and would lose the opportunity to be part of the next wave of job-creating, lifesaving healthcare innovations.
Let’s not drive people apart. Let’s keep Somerville moving forward. Please vote “no” on Question 3.
Signed by 74 members of the Somerville community, linked here.
